|
This image and text piece presents some of the issues which preoccupy
me in my role as an artist working with video and digital media. Most
of my works are concerned with ways in which new media technologies
are changing relationships between audience, artefact and gallery. Representations
of the body and its virtual and/or remote presence are central to a
number of these projects, and build on my early background in installation
and performance work.
The Imaginary Internal Organs of a Cyborg 1 is a CDROM which
takes the physical form of the cyborg as a vehicle for exploring philosophical
and cultural spaces. The piece employs digital techniques to build up
layers of images and sounds - these range from the use of low resolution
QuickCam video sequences to 3D computer modelling, from interviews with
surgeons and medical researchers to the use of ready-made images from
the Wellcome Photo Library and from PhotoDisc. While on the one hand
the images appear to represent a body, or a series of bodies, my intention
has been to create a transfigurative work which investigates ways in
which our sense of self has a fluidity that defies a spatial containment
within the universal body. The focus of the work is the
impermanence and dissolution of boundaries between the human and machine,
the inside and outside and the natural and the artificial. The sense
of self that this cyborg has is based upon an awareness of unbounded
territories. Christine Battersby 2 contrasts the cognitive semantic
view of the body as a container for the inner self, all bodies basically
the same, over which cultural differences are laid, with the body as
an open permeable and fissuring space. Battersby states that:
...feminists need - for political ends - to exploit the difficulties
of containing female identity within the schemata provided by classical
science and metaphysics, and use the resources provided by contemporary
science and the history of philosophy to think selves, bodies and
boundaries in more revolutionary terms. In this respect I agree with
Donna Haraway in the alliance with the cyborg. It is time to turn
our backs on those forms of feminist theory that castigate all science
and all Western philosophy as rationalist, masculinist and weapons
of the enemy. It is time to investigate the imaginative schemata that
old philosophies and new sciences offer us for re-visioning the female
self. 3
It is an attempt to re-vision and imagine the female self which underlies
The Imaginary Internal Organs of a Cyborg. The first stage
of the project, completed in spring 1996, involved exploring the heart,
a rich and contested site, and one which offered up a turbulent eddy
of associations. The heart is simultaneously considered as a Cartesian
pumping machine contained within the body and as the seat of Romantic
love, which seeps out of the confines of the body, merging fantasy with
flesh. The ability to feel and express emotion, especially love, is
commonly held as that which sets the human aside from the machine. In
science fiction writing it is more often the brain that becomes the
focus for exploring cyborg identities, this is epitomised by the recurring
theme of a human personality - the contents of a persons brain
- being transferred onto a computer chip. As the project developed I
turned my attention to the brain which is treated as the site for exploring
distributed memory, neural networks and artificial intelligence. I then
concentrated on the stomach which embodies ideas of the digestion and
assimilation of data and becomes the centre of the cyborg as a flow
of information. Here too are references to everyday associations of
the body with emotional states, and its attendant focus on nausea and
appetite.
The images and sounds that make up The Imaginary Internal Organs
of a Cyborg are a collection which form a figuration of the cyborg
- it parodies the world of advertising and the culture of medicine.
Sarah Kember has argued that figuration (as opposed to representation)
has a self-conscious relationship to epistemological structures. Figuration
is representation plus. It offers a partial and situated knowledge and
tends towards shifting subject positions, it:
...is an alternative verbal or visual language which embodies
a transformation in the terms of knowledge, power and subjectivity.
It strategically resists and competes with the structures of patriarchy
and the Enlightenment - specifically a gendered and hierarchical dualism
which priviledges culture over nature, mind over body, male over female.
Its usual mode of operation is parody. 4
The body has long been used by women artists as a site for intervention
5 (Betterton, 1996) and the cyborg body, or bodies, provide a rich philosophical
and cultural locus. This territory is unfixed and constantly shifting,
more like duned desert than solid ground, with cyborg identities appearing
like mirages, shimmering and difficult to make out, disappearing and
then re-emerging changed elsewhere. I have found the metaphor of the
mirage particularly useful as I try to imagine the cyborg body: the
mirage is an optical illusion in which images of distant objects, hidden
or beyond the horizon, become visible by the refraction of light. New
medical imagining technologies have brought images of the interior of
our corporeal landscape to us which are invisible to our
unassisted vision. The cyborg has occupied a space somewhere just beyond
our event horizon and images of the augmented body appear before us
in science fiction films, medical journals and popular science TV programmes
like images from a place just beyond our reach. Each of the cyborg identities
is a refraction of our earth-bound desires and fantasies about our bodies,
of our drive to improve our longevity, to extend our physical and mental
capabilities or to circumvent social and cultural restrictions.
Issues of gender permeate the piece, though I deliberately chose to
work with internal organs which were not sex-specific in an attempt
to move away from a biologically determinist reading of femininity.
However I am mindful of the problems of adopting a liberal theory stance
on the body, as Donna Haraway argues:
Liberal theory was a resource for feminists, but only at the
expense of renouncing anything specific about womens voice and
position, and carefully avoiding difference, for example race, among
women. The neutral body was always unmarked, white and
masculine 6.
Rather than trying to visualise a non-specific or universal body by
focussing on its potential for neutrality, it may be more useful to
shift the emphasis to the position and identity of the eye that looks
at it. Baxandalls 7 idea of the period eye provides
a useful framework for looking at images of the body. Simply put, the
period eye refers to the skills of interpretation and the
cultural context that viewers in a particular chronological and geographical
location bring with them when they look at images. The eye with which
we view representations of the contemporary body is located in a period
where we have become familiar with images of simulacra and our late
twentieth century beau ideal frequently turns out to be surgically altered
or digitally enhanced. The contemporary notion of ideal beauty incorporates
a post modern philosophy of transience - a belief that the nature of
being is subject to change, that our physical states need not be fixed
by nature, but can be altered utilising new technologies such as genetic
engineering, surgery and pharmaceuticals to produce a cyborg which might
embody excellence.
If the cyborg can act as a philosophical space,then it is a territory
criss-crossed with tracks left by malevolent super-machismo man-machine
hybrids from sci-fi films and books - these are the emotionless killing
machines that figured strongly in the popular culture of the 1980s,
whose bodies were high tech, high performance weapons. Overlaying these
are other traces: the cyborg as a chimera, a blend of human and animal
organs, the embodiment of wild fancy and imagined horror 8. The chimera
is chemically fixed, rather like a photograph, its hybrid
form is held together with pharmaceuticals which prevent the human body
rejecting donor organs, and the relationship between the host and foreign
bodies, once established is monitored by imaging technologies. Here
also is the mark of the analogue cyborg, the woman with the mechanical
heart valves or the artificial hips, the child with the metal plate
in its head or the steel pins in its shins.
The cyborg occupies spaces between flesh and information, straddling
the boundaries between the natural and artificial. We have become used
to the notion of the body as meat and while many cultural
theorists emphasise that this view is not a continuation of the Enlightenment
Flight from the Body they pay little attention to the hardships
and pain that a journey of physical augmentation or alteration entails.
The transformative journey from human to post-human invokes a keen awareness
of the physicality of the flesh through the experience of surgical and
pharmaceutical intervention. The body is meat and we need cleavers,
knives and saws to open it, clamps and braces to hold it open while
it is worked upon, staples and stitches to close it up. Its meatiness
is prone to rotting and degeneration, and renders the corpus in need
of preservation.
Stored in formaldehyde and held frozen in cryogenic tanks, opened butterfly-like,
brains are a sign of the mysterious flowering of our intellect. Imaging
technologies are used to expose the inner workings typified by the vast
and uncharted territory of the synapses. Rows of jars in museums: the
brain of a serial killer, Einstein's brain, so many uncontextualised
and unexplained disembodied brains free-floating, held as the measure
of criminality or genius. We have become used to the idea that our intellect,
somehow seated in our brain, is what separates us from other animals.
The development of our brain, in particular its larger size, is used
as an indicator of our superiority and elevated position in relation
to other primates. Medical imaging systems expose the formerly invisible
processes and recesses of the body to a technocratic gaze, drawing out
our innermost functions from the private to the public sphere of visual
culture. Here again is a confusion of boundary, a subsidence of the
private into the public and an eruption of the public into the private,
as ultrasound images of the foetus and MRI scans of the brain are tucked
into family albums, passed round at parties alongside snapshots of the
exterior body.
The heart of the cyborg beats in time to the metronomic pacemaker. Airbags
are inserted along collapsing arteries by surgeons trained on virtual
reality simulations. Metal valves click like old clocks. Animals are
bio-engineered for human transplant compatibility. *** The meat-market
economy of Third world organ donation is wiped out by the
increased use of pigs from medical farms which are owned and controlled
by the First world medical infrastructure. Thus each operation
and transplant forms an integral part of the financial structure of
the architecture of medicine.
The Imaginary Internal Organs of a Cyborg returns us to
the malleable architecture of the imagined cyborg body, to the cyborg
stomach where there are remnants and semi digested fragments of many
a cyborgian fantasy. These include traces of the digital cyborg which
has become immaterial - a pure information space - with a digital body
of algorithms, which ingests zeros and ones of pure information
like an expensive drug. Virtual cakes and sweets lie next to real ones,
eye-candy and cake to fuel and fatten the meat. Performance enhancing
vitamins, steroids, antibiotics, artificial hormones create a soup of
biotechnology navigated by self-propelling pills containing bite sized
nano-surgeons. This cyborg has devoured medical science, pulled the
surgeon in through the wound and kept him prisoner within
walls of flesh. Like the woman who swallowed the spider, augmentation
wriggles and wriggles inside her. The fairy cakes, lamb chops and fresh
vegetables all hold within them the traces of a drive to improve performance
and longevity: faint tastes of pesticide, the feel of waxy skin and
the endlessly fresh bloom of irradiation. The stomach contents of this
cyborg are held in a small space, the stomach tucked to create a flatter
outer appearance and the intestine shortened to make room for a Hi NRG
Carbohydrate Converter and more information technology.
The cyborg body as a subject for philosophical enquiry is, like all
bodies, inscribed with the values and beliefs of the culture from which
it emerges. Biotechnical advances and cybernetic developments embed
the cyborg within military and industrial commodity 8, but its identity
splits and fissures as we import ideas of Artificial Intelligence and
neural networks which challenge our notions of what it is to be human.
There are two linked concepts, interpolation 9 and interpellation 9,
which may help explain our fascination with the notion of the cyborg.
They both contain the sense of interruption 9 - the first in relation
to tampering with matter by the insertion of new or strange material;
the second in relation to the grabbing of attention. Mathematicians
and computer programmers commonly use the term iterative interpolation
9 to mean a series of digitally defined, sequential alterations to a
model or image, which cause it to change from one structure to another.
The cyborg bodies discussed previously are the first iterations in our
journey from the human to the post-human and offer us the opportunity
to fantasise about the process of continual transformation and the power
this implies. In Cultural Studies, interpellation is used to describe
the process by which a subject feels they are being hailed 9 and considers
how we recognise ourselves in the representations and messages offered
to us. As the cyborg in all its manifestations becomes ever present
in popular culture, so does our fascination with cyborg bodies. This
begs the question: why do we embrace these new forms with such vigour
and what does this recognition imply for our sense of self?
1 Prophet, Jane. The Imaginary Internal Organs of a Cyborg. CDROM. Email:
jane@cairn.demon.co.uk
2 Battersby, Christine. Her Body/Her Boundaries: Gender and the Metaphysics
of Containment, in Journal of Philosophy and the Visual Arts: The Body.
The Academy Group: London, 1993. pp30-39
3 ibid p38
4 Kember, Sarah. Unpublished notes which accompanied her seminar given
at Wired Women: Virtual Worlds/Real Lives. A conference at Univerity
of Portsmouth 8th March 1997.
5 Betterton, Rosemary. An Intimate Distance: Women, Artists and the
Body. Routledge: London, 1996
6 Haraway, Donna 1990 p148
7 Baxandall, Michael Painting and Experience in Fifteenth Century Italy.
Clarendon:Oxford, 1972.
Levidow, Les and Robins, Kevin. Cyborg Worlds: the military information
society. Free Association books: London, 1989
8 The Shorter Oxford English Dictionary defines a chimera as either
a grotesque monster in archaeological or painting etrms, or figuratively
as a wild fancy or unfounded conception. The Shorter Oxford English
Dictionary Volume 1, A-Markworthy. Clarendon Press: Oxford, 1991. p325
|